Our very cool, fully-restored soda fountain.

We are always adding and changing flavors…that’s the fun of making ice cream! But you can be sure we will keep the classics around and we would love to hear your ideas for new flavors. Please stop in often so you are sure not to miss one of our “new creations”.

Our flavor selections change daily, so when you visit The Comfy Cow, you may find any one of the following flavors available:

Georgia Butter Pecan

A classic favorite with the best fresh roasted buttered pecans straight from Georgia

Cake Batter Up

Imagine the taste of a freshly baked yellow cake, straight from Grandma’s oven with a tall glass of ice cold milk

Dulche de Leche de Salte (Salty Caramel)

The most luscious caramel flavor imaginable, perfectly combined with just a touch of sea salt. You’ve got to try this!

Chocolate

No need to embellish. The Best. The One. The Only. CHOCOLATE!

Chocolate Chip Off the Old Block

The perfect combination. Our pure, creamy vanilla ice cream bursting with decadent pieces of rich, dark chocolate

Freshly Roasted Coffee

Tastes just like the aroma of a freshly brewed pot of coffee on a crisp fall morning

Cozy Booths

Cookie Monster Dough

Huge chunks of cookie dough snatched from the Cookie Monster’s cookie jar combined with our cookie dough flavored ice cream

Vanilla

The perfect blend of Tahitian and Madagascar vanilla beans make this the ultimate vanilla…there’s nothing plain about it

Minty Chocolate Chippy

A perennial favorite…cool, mint-flavored ice cream loaded with bits of chocolate chips

Banana Nana Fofana

You’ll swing from the highest tree to get your hands on this flavor! Made from the ripest, sweetest bananas…nothing else needed

Strawberry Fields Forever

Made with the plumpest, juiciest, most mouthwatering strawberries available. A real American classic

Peanut Peanut Butter Butter

If you really love peanut butter, you’ll flip over this one! Trust us!

Cookies and Cream

It’s almost 3 o’clock, the bell is about to ring and all you can think of is that plate full of Oreos and a tall glass of ice cold milk.

Vermont Maple Walnut

We’ve tapped into an old favorite. We use 100% pure Vermont maple syrup combined with a heaping helping of fresh roasted walnut pieces to make this classic flavor a true standout.

Prices (subject to change)

Ice Cream

Ice Cream Sundaes

Ice Cream Drinks

Novelty Items

Take Home Ice Cream

• Pint      $5.50
• Quart      $9.75

Ice Cream Pies

• Slice      $3.95
• Whole      $28.95