You can pick our next flavor


We have lots of flavors that no one has ever tasted and it just wouldn’t be fair to keep them all to ourselves. Now is your chance to choose one of our next featured flavors. Make your choice below and the winning flavor will be available on August 1. Voting is open from June 15 through July 15.

Mexican Chocolate Ole — Our Signature Chocolate ice cream with a hint of spicy cayenne and savory cinnamon. Ole!

Chocolate Orange — If you’ve never experienced the combination of these two very distinctive flavors, you’ve got to try this. It’s a perfect match!

Chocolate Malted — Just like a chocolate malted shake with large pieces of frozen malted milk balls. Yum!

Choose the next flavor!

  • Mexican Chocolate Ole (44%, 908 Votes)
  • Chocolate Orange (20%, 404 Votes)
  • Chocolate Malted (36%, 755 Votes)

Total Voters: 2,067

Loading ... Loading ...
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
mo1039 5 pts

I love The Comfy Cow!!!!! When will you have blind pig again?

please get a campfire one!!!!!

YAH CHOCLATE WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH

YAH CHOCLATE WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH

We neeeeed malted ---- ooo ooo ooo ---- ice cream with malted milk balls --- love it, love it, love it.....

Hey Janet,

Thanks for the comments. Our sorbets are all natural and we do not use
splenda or any other artificial sweetener. As for the aftertaste you are
talking about, I would imagine you haven't tried ours since no one has ever
mentioned any aftertaste since the day we opened, so I'm a little surprised.
Our sorbets are very popular and we do offer them so people who are lactose
intolerant have an alternative. As for us being for 'EVERYBODY', that has
never been our intent. All we ever have wanted to do and be was really good
at what we do, and that;s offer a great ice cream and a great ice cream
experience. We could never please everyone, even if we tried. I know that
there are more sorbet options out there and I'm glad you have all those
other alternatives. Happy eating!

Wish you had MORE VARIETY in your SORBET FLAVORS. I'm lactose intolerant & it's GREAT that you serve
sorbet, but what about being more creative &, while you're at it, delete the aftertaste, too? We dorbet eaters get tired of the same old, same old. Your competitors at Graeter's & Smoothie King offer MORE SORBET FLAVORS. I'm sure the aftertaste is due to using something using Splenda. Try using a sweetener based on the Stevia plant. There's Only Sweet, Truvia & others a health food store could suggest. Result" Nooo aftertaste & you'd even be helping diabetics, or those in this community needing to watch sugar, experience ice cream, many FOR THE FIRST TIME. And isn't Comfy Cow supposed to hep EVERYBODY in this community?

Not currently, but we do have fat free sorbets.

Does Comfy produce sugar free ice creams?

I love mexican food so this is a no brainer.

It's "first lady" (your first customer). How about creating a "raw" non-dairy frozen dessert, say, for example, made from coconut milk. Cafe Gratitude in San Francisco has some good recipes, if you ever wanted to check it out. Those of use who like to try "alternative" types of foods always appreciate an "alternative".

Had this flavor in Gelato and it was amazing. Puts me in mind of the Hot Chocolate in the movie Chocolat.

Old Fashioned Bubble Gum PLEASE!
You can't get it anywhere in the city!
xo!

YES! Bring back the Red Velvet Cake please!!!

Chocolate and Orange will be mooooooooooooo wonderful!

Bring the Bourbon Ball back !!!!!

Glad to see Chocolate Malted in the lead. : )

you da man...you da cow!

Bourbon Ball will be back on July 1st!!!

Bring bourbon ball back first!!!

You need to make all three......and don't forget the rocky road......
Jan and Jim

I LOVE chocolate and orange!!!!!

Chocolate and spicy go hand in hand. Bring on the OLE!

Can't get much closer than that! Bring on the Chocolate Orange!

Chocolate Orange sounds really yummy!! I'm waiting for Chocolate Peppermint to return. THAT needs to be on the permanent list!

Mexican Ole has got to win and become permanent. It will beat out the candy at Coco's on Bardstown Rd. And everyone who knoww anything knows that choclate and cayenne pepper and cinnamon together are heavely.

BRING BACK RED VELVET CAKE AND LEMON CREAM WITH RASPBERRY!!!!

ABSOLUTELY I WANT TO COME AND GET THE CHOCOLATE MALTED> IT SHOULD BE A PERMANENT FLAVOR!!! I ALSO WANT A CHOCOLATE MALT (my personal favorite thing in the whole world) TO BE MADE OUT OF THIS BRILLIANT ICE CREAM FLAVOR!!! THIS IS TORTURE... WAITING UNTIL AUGUST 1, 2010!!!! WE ARE THERE DUDE!

I vote for the vegan flavor.

Yeah I hope it is the OLE I love me some spice :)

Conversation from Facebook

Thomas Newman
Thomas Newman

Cinnamon Roll for sure

The Comfy Cow
The Comfy Cow

BTW. We're calling the Coffee and Doughnuts one, "The Policeman's Special" :)